Competition doesn’t always produce better performance

An inter­est­ing test results show that humans per­form bet­ter when com­pet­ing against teams/individuals of a lower class. i.e. A good devel­oper would work faster when com­pet­ing against a new­bie or a worse-performing developer.

This could mean a lot, and per­haps explain why some places can­not man­age sim­pler tasks they did man­age before bring­ing in some heavy duty expert.

Quote from the article:

Another light in which it might be infor­ma­tive to view this study is with respect to research into what’s called “stereo­type threat.” This is a well-known effect in which stig­ma­tized groups — such as African-Americans or women — per­form worse when prompted to focus on neg­a­tive stereo­types about their group. Thus, African-Americans tak­ing the SAT, if asked to check a box list­ing their race before the test, will per­form worse than if they were not pro­moted to do so. Con­versely, Asian stu­dents asked to mark their race tend to per­form bet­ter, because of pos­i­tive stereo­types about aca­d­e­mic achievement.

Or, take the case of a female, Asian stu­dent — prompted to think about her Asian iden­tity, she is likely to per­form bet­ter; prompted to think about her female iden­tity, she is likely to do worse.

Leave a Reply